“The Possibility of an Afterlife”: An Interpretation and Defense of D.H. Lund’s View of the Self as an Immaterial Center of Subjective States
نویسنده:
Zainab Amiri
،
مقاله نشریه: Theosophia Islamica » سال 2022 شماره 1
کلیدواژه:
Possibility of Afterlife
،
David Lund
،
self
،
phenomenology
،
Interactionist Dualism
،
Transceiver Theory
چکیده:
The question of the probability of life after death has been of the highest importance throughout the ages for great numbers of people. The denial of its possibility is frequently based on a conception of a person as a completely material (or physical) being by appealing to both empirical evidence and philosophical argument. In this study, based on Lund’s view, we will present and defend a mind-body dualism in which the immaterial self does not consist in, and might not depend for its existence upon, the existence of the body and so might continue to exist after bodily death. The close association of these two distinct entities is due to a causal connection — a connection that fails to establish that the physical brings the mental into existence and is compatible with theories that the source of consciousness is not in the brain (e.g., the transceiver theory). In view of this, the continued existence of the self beyond the death of its body would be not only metaphysically possible but might be in accord with the laws of nature (i.e., naturally possible) as well. Arguments will be advanced in support of this form of dualism. They may be classified as follows: 1. the nature of the self (as known through acquaintance or phenomenology) and what it is to be a person, 2. Interactionist dualism and “transceiver” theory, 3. The self as an ontologically basic particular that experiences the world.
The question of the probability of life after death has been of the highest importance throughout the ages for great numbers of people. The denial of its possibility is frequently based on a conception of a person as a completely material (or physical) being by appealing to both empirical evidence and philosophical argument. In this study, based on Lund’s view, we will present and defend a mind-body dualism in which the immaterial self does not consist in, and might not depend for its existence upon, the existence of the body and so might continue to exist after bodily death. The close association of these two distinct entities is due to a causal connection — a connection that fails to establish that the physical brings the mental into existence and is compatible with theories that the source of consciousness is not in the brain (e.g., the transceiver theory). In view of this, the continued existence of the self beyond the death of its body would be not only metaphysically possible but might be in accord with the laws of nature (i.e., naturally possible) as well. Arguments will be advanced in support of this form of dualism. They may be classified as follows: 1. the nature of the self (as known through acquaintance or phenomenology) and what it is to be a person, 2. Interactionist dualism and “transceiver” theory, 3. The self as an ontologically basic particular that experiences the world.
“The Possibility of an Afterlife”: An Interpretation and Defense of D.H. Lund’s View of the Self as an Immaterial Center of Subjective States
1/1/2022 12:00:00 AM
The Semantic Network of Government and State-making in the Late Naꜥini’s View
نویسنده:
Rajabali-ꜥ Esfandiar
،
مقاله نشریه: Journal of Islamic Political Studies » سال 2023 شماره 1
The Semantics of Ḍaraba in the Verse 34 of Surah An-Nisa
نویسنده:
Sayyed Ahmadzadeh
،
مقاله نشریه: Textual and Translation Analysis in Islamic Studies » سال 2023 شماره 1
An evaluation of William Craig and Armstrong's debate on the existence of God
نویسنده:
Taebe Khosravi
،
مقاله نشریه: Theosophia Islamica » سال 2022 شماره 2
The Translation of Metaphors in the Holy Qur’ān: An Investigation of Chapters Eighteen to Thirty
نویسنده:
Samad Mirza Suzani
،
مقاله نشریه: Textual and Translation Analysis in Islamic Studies » سال 2023 شماره 3
The Status and Foundations of the Right to Peace and Security in Islamic Thought
نویسنده:
Seyed Javad Varaei
،
مقاله نشریه: Journal of Islamic Political Studies » سال 2019 شماره 2
The Comparative Study of the Political Interpretation of the Quran in Yūsuf Qarḍāwi and ʿAllāmam Ṭabāṭabā's Thought
مقاله نشریه: Journal of Islamic Political Studies » سال 2021 شماره 4
Swinburne, the Gift of Life, and the Soul
نویسنده:
Amir Dastmalchian
،
مقاله نشریه: Theosophia Islamica » سال 2021 شماره 2
Mirza Naʾini and the Scope of the Government’s Jurisdiction and Duties
مقاله نشریه: Journal of Islamic Political Studies » سال 2022 شماره 7
The Semantic Field of the Moral Words “Marouf”, “Munkar” and “Sin” and Their English Translations
نویسنده:
Mahbube Noura
،
مقاله نشریه: Textual and Translation Analysis in Islamic Studies » سال 2023 شماره 3
Transcendental Theosophy and Political Science: An Introduction to the Possibility of Basing Political Sciences on the Concept of Transcendental Theosophy
نویسنده:
Mohammad Pezeshgi
،
مقاله نشریه: Journal of Islamic Political Studies » سال 2019 شماره 1